How to make Turkey Breast with Stuffing Thanksgiving Dinner for Two

Planning a Thanksgiving dinner for two but not sure where to start?   Getting ready for the holiday when cooking for two is easier than you think.  This menu is all about simplicity and very little fuss.  This guide will walk you through how to make a turkey breast with stuffing thanksgiving dinner for two .  Hopefully, it inspires confidence to make a holiday-worthy dinner when two share the meal.

Jump to:

• Small Thanksgiving Dinner Menu
• How to Prepare Thanksgiving Dinner for Two
• Up to 1 month before
• 3 days before
• 1 day before
• How to Make a Turkey Breast with Stuffing Thanksgiving Dinner for Two
• 3 ½  hours before serving
• Make Ahead Sides
• 45 minutes prior to serving
• 30 minutes prior to serving
• 15 minutes prior to serving
• Serving time
• Turkey Breast Carving Tips
• Leftover Turkey Breast Recipes
• Freezing and Reheating Turkey Breast
• How to make Turkey Breast with Stuffing Thanksgiving Dinner for Two Recipe

Small Thanksgiving Dinner Menu

This thanksgiving dinner menu may be scaled down in size but not in flavor.  Turkey and stuffing are a perfect pair on the plate and we cook them together in one pan, not only cutting down on dirty dishes but also creating a stuffing packed with savory poultry flavor.   

As an homage to my grandmother’s stuffing, we will combine sage, onion, celery, wine, chicken broth and an apple for a flavorful turkey stuffing.  Instead of small cubes of sandwich bread, we opted for larger chunks of ciabatta.  The bigger pieces retained some chew even as they soaked up flavors from the turkey. 

We will roast the turkey breast on top of the stuffing and when the breast is done, we will pop just the stuffing back into the oven crisping the top.  It’s a perfect mix of moist and crisp edges that is guaranteed to win over your dinner guest.

For a final holiday flourish, we will make ahead a homemade gravy that is so much better than any store-bought gravy or gravy packet.  If you don’t have time to make-ahead, it comes together quickly while the roasted turkey rests. I usually make a week ahead, thaw in the refrigerator the night before and then reheat while the turkey rests. 

Maple Roasted Carrots and salted maple pepitas, A simple warm spinach salad and no fuss mashed potatoes -- we will whip the dishes together while the turkey breast rests. 

Since we will spend most of our effort on the main meal, let’s leave the bread baking to our favorite bakery.  Be sure to call ahead to order your pie or preferred dessert.

Here are the dishes included in this small Thanksgiving dinner for two menu:

• Turkey Breast with Stuffing – cooked together in one pan, not just to cut down on dirty dishes but also to create a stuffing packed with savory poultry flavor. Using a turkey breast (instead of a whole bird) makes carving easier and eliminates the challenge of trying to sync the cooking times for white and dark meat.
• Homemade Gravy (without drippings)
• Mashed Potatoes
• Apple Spinach Salad with Warm Bacon Dressing
• Maple Roasted Carrots with salted maple pepitas and white bean puree
• Jellied Cranberry Sauce – yup, the stuff out of the can.
• Store-bought pie or dessert

How to Prepare Thanksgiving Dinner for Two

There’s no need to plan out your Thanksgiving to-do list because we’ve done it for you.  Take a couple of minutes to read through this step-by-step guide, which starts with all the little things you can accomplish a few days or weeks ahead. 

Check off the small things every day, and come Thanksgiving, what’s left will be totally manageable.

Up to 1 month before

Make-ahead and freeze Ina Garten’s homemade gravy – no drippings are required and it’s a winner.    The night before serving the Thanksgiving dinner, pull it out of the freezer and thaw it in the refrigerator.

• Create a shopping list.  For this recipe and turkey breast with stuffing and the warm spinach salad you can generate a shopping list by saving the recipes in your collections (use the button at the top of the recipe card).
• Order or buy a turkey breast.  Depending on how many leftovers you want, buy a whole breast (for a lot of leftovers) or a half breast.  Keep in freezer up to 3 days prior to cooking.
• Order you pie for pick up the day before Thanksgiving.

3 days before

• Defrost your turkey breast.  Thawing a frozen turkey breast takes time and patience.  The best way is to thaw the breast in the coldest area of the fridge with a pan underneath to catch any drips.
• Buy perishables.  Buy spinach, potatoes, and ciabatta bread for the stuffing.  Wash the spinach leaves now, dry well, and store by packing them in paper towels in a plastic bag in the refrigerator.

1 day before

• Set the table.  Put out all the place settings, decorations and serving dishes – this way you won’t have to worry about it later.

• Salt the turkey breast.  The salted turkey needs to be refrigerated, uncovered for at least 2 hours before cooking up to 24 hours.

How to Make a Turkey Breast with Stuffing Thanksgiving Dinner for Two

For the big day, we’ve figured out just the right order and timing to pull together the rest of the feast. 

3 ½  hours before serving

The size of the turkey breast will determine when you will begin prepping the stuffing and roasting.  

Split breast (3 lbs). You will want to start the preparations 3 ½ hours before serving time if cooking a 3 lb breast.   Allowing 30 minutes for preparing the stuffing and preheating the oven, 1 ¾  hours for roasting turkey time and 30 minutes up to an hour for the turkey to rest. 

If you have a larger breast you will need to add more roasting time, up to an additional 20 minutes per pound.

Here are the tasks to start 2 - 3 ½ hours before when you want to sit at the table:

• Preheat the oven to 325 degrees.
• Prepare the Stuffing.  Just a reminder that the turkey and stuffing are cooked together in one pan, not just to cut down on dirty dishes but also to create a stuffing packed with savory poultry flavor. Start by cutting the ciabatta into 1-inch cubes.  If you cannot find ciabatta do not substitute sour dough as the flavor is too overpowering.  Instead substitute another rustic, mild-tasting white bread. Now, sauté the onion, celery and garlic in oil in the roasting pan.  Add the remaining stuffing ingredients, tossing using tongs or your hands until the bread is evenly coated.

Make Ahead Sides

Make your maple roasted carrots and bean puree - To get ahead, you can prepare the maple roasted with salted pepitas and white bean purée up to 6 hours in advance.

Store each component separately in airtight containers—be sure the carrots cool to room temperature before sealing. You can even leave everything on the counter for up to 6 hours.  When ready to serve, warm the purée in the microwave (about 1 minute – making it easier to spread), spread it on a serving platter, arrange the room-temperature carrots on top, and garnish with extra herbs, pepitas, and pomegranate.

45 minutes prior to serving

• Peel, cut and boil potatoes.  Place 1.5 pounds of potatoes cut into evenly-sized chunks in a large pot of cold water, so that the water line sits about 1 inch above the potatoes.  Add 1 teaspoon Sea salt into the water. Bring water to a boil, reduce heat to medium-high to maintain the boil and continue to cook until fork tender, about 10 – 12 minutes.  
• Drain water from pot and mash the potatoes to reach your desired consistency. Fold in 1-2 Tablespoons butter, about ¼ cup milk, 2 Tablespoons sour cream and salt, to taste, keep warm in oven until ready to serve.

30 minutes prior to serving

• Cook the bacon and make the dressing for the Warm Spinach salad.

15 minutes prior to serving

• Reheat homemade gravy.  Spoon the gravy into a cold sauce pan.  Turn the skillet on low heat and let the gravy come to temperature slowly, stirring frequently to avoid the gravy burning and to remove any lumps.  Simmer on low until ready to serve.
• Assemble Salad. Toss together the salad ingredients with the warm bacon maple dressing

Serving time

• Eat Pie.  Sometime later when you have room!

Turkey Breast Carving Tips

Before carving you will want to let your chicken rest, this will avoid the breast meat shredding as you slice it and allows the juices to redistribute throughout the meat for juicy slices of turkey.

• Use a sharp carving knife.  You will want to put away your chef’s knife and grab a carving or deboning knife along with a two-pronged fork.

Transfer the breast and layer on top of the stuffing in the roasting pan and drizzle with some gravy.

Love this recipe? Please leave a star rating and review in the comments below! And don't forget to subscribe to Our Table 4 2 for even more cooking for two recipes and tips.

Leftover Turkey Breast Recipes

Here are a few of my favorite recipes to “use up” leftover turkey.

• Leftover wild rice turkey soup
• Swap out chicken for leftover turkey breast in chicken broccoli pasta casserole recipe
• Swap out chicken for leftover turkey breast in the chicken salad with pasta and dried cherries or pesto chicken salad
• Stuff your baked squash with leftover turkey and stuffing by. Follow the directions in how to cook your squash in this stuffed squash recipe. Reheat your turkey and stuffing leftovers then stuff your squash. Enjoy!

Freezing and Reheating Turkey Breast

According to the National Turkey Federation, the best way to store leftover turkey is to slice the meat from the bone, seal up in airtight container and refrigerate within two hours of serving.  Store in refrigerate and eat up to four days.

If you are planning to freeze it, it’s best to freeze it within one day of cooking for optimal texture and taste.  However, leftover turkey can be frozen up to 6 months.

To thaw:  Place the bag or container in the fridge for at least one day, up to two days.  You can also use the microwave if the container is small enough to rotate inside, allowing to defrost evenly.   Do not thaw at room temperature. 

If using in soups or baked casserole, you will not need to defrost first.  Simply add to the dish and cook until warmed through.

To reheat in oven:  Put the turkey in a baking pan, add a small amount broth or white wine, cover the pan with foil, and heat it gently in a 300°F oven until it is warmed through. You can pour off any remaining liquid from the pan.

To reheat in microwave: Put the turkey in a microwave-safe container, add a bit of broth or white wine, and cover the turkey with a damp paper towel. Make sure the tray can rotate in the microwave – if it’s too big, use the oven.